
Sometimes a plaque is just a plaque. At Hilltop Park, you walk past one on your way to the playground or a walking trail, and after a while you stop seeing it.
But a few weeks ago, someone stopped and read it. Another resident did a little digging. What he found stopped Easttown Township in its tracks.
Within days, the township paused its controversial plan to put a new police headquarters and township office building in the northwest corner of the park. Then it set its sights on an office building on Lancaster Avenue.
Five minutes online
So what caused the sudden about-face?
It wasn’t the blue “Save Hilltop Park” lawn signs, or the residents’ Facebook group, where people had been talking about taking legal action. It wasn’t the more than 40 neighbors who packed the last two supervisors’ meetings.

What stopped officials cold was a 1999 agreement they said they hadn’t known about until residents brought it to their attention. Resident Rob Gardner told supervisors Monday night that it took him about five minutes to find online, once the plaque told him what to look for.
The plaque credits a Chester County open space grant with helping to pay for the park. In exchange for that grant, Easttown signed a covenant with the county, signed by then-board chair Howard Flaxman. It stipulates that 20.52 acres of Hilltop Park “shall be utilized perpetually for park and recreational purposes only.” The proposed building sat squarely inside those acres.
The township had already worked around one obstacle. The Odell family, who donated the Hilltop land to Easttown in 1996, had put limits on new buildings in the deed of gift. Supervisors recently signed a clarifying agreement with the Odell heirs that would have allowed a new building in the park.
A covenant with the county was something else entirely. Only the county can enforce it or waive it. If the county took the township to court, Easttown would have to pay the county’s legal fees and the cost of restoring the land, along with its own lawyers.
“I did not know about it. Staff did not know about it,” said township solicitor Andrew Rau. He said the covenant was hard to find because it doesn’t list the property’s parcel number.
Chester County leaves no doubt about where it stands. In a statement to SAVVY, county spokesman Andrew Kreider confirmed that the proposed site “is within the limits of the property covered by the 1999 County Declaration.” He added that a municipal or police use there, “for anything other than park, recreation, or open space use,” would violate it.
“The County expects all parties to honor Declarations regarding taxpayer-funded property acquisitions that provide for perpetual park, recreation, and open space use,” Kreider said.
Easttown Supervisors Board Chair Sean Axel opened Monday’s meeting by announcing that design work on the park site had been paused while the township reviews “these additional covenant matters.”
“Hilltop is a township gem,” Axel said. But he added that the board “feels very strongly” about the need for a new building for police, who he said have worked “in building conditions that we would all deem unacceptable” for more than a decade.
Three options, one new one
Two weeks after a 4-to-1 vote that would have helped clear the way for a $13 million municipal building inside Hilltop Park, supervisors voted unanimously to look at other options.
For about $28,000, they hired Kimmel Architecture to study three of them. Two have been studied and rejected before:
- Renovate and expand the current police and administration building. Supervisor Michael Wacey recalled that the idea was dropped a few years ago because “the footprint didn’t support the building that we need” and because it came with an estimated $20M price tag.
- Tear down the current building and build a new police station and offices on the same site.
- Buy 431 Lancaster Ave. in Devon, and either renovate it or knock it down and rebuild.

Easttown Township is studying the feasibility of moving its police and municipal offices to this site on Lancaster Ave. in Devon.
For decades, 431 Lancaster has been home to BHHS Fox & Roach, which is moving two miles west to larger quarters in Berwyn. The four-story, Class B office building sits on 3.1 acres. It was built in 1988, updated in 2019 and recently listed for sale or lease. No asking price is listed; the township would negotiate one with the owner.
At 41,000 sq. ft., the building is about twice the size the township needs. Presumably, Easttown would try to lease out the extra space.
“We’re caught between options that are expensive, more expensive and most expensive,” said Supervisor Alex Bosco, describing how the cost of new police and staff facilities keeps going up.
Architect Martin Kimmel said his firm would move quickly. He expects to present the report to the board in January.
Paused, not dead
Gardner’s 11-page handout to the board laid out the legal “protections” for the park and urged the township to “take Hilltop Park off the table and find another site.” At the podium, he asked why none of it had come up before: “This has been ongoing for 10 or so years.”

Resident Rob Gardner poses questions to the board about its plan to build in HIlltop Park at Monday’s meeting of the Easttown Board of Supervisors. About 40 concerned residents attended the meeting.
Wacey and one other supervisor agreed. They backed a motion to permanently drop the northwest corner from consideration instead of just pausing it.
“I think a lot of money has been spent developing something on property that [it] couldn’t go [on],” said Berwyn resident Michele Cruise, speaking in favor of the motion. “I think you should just listen to the intent of the gift … and I think you should honor this and do the right thing.”
The motion failed, 2-3.
The supervisors who voted no said they didn’t want to rule anything out before the studies come back. “I don’t want to start striking things out before we even analyze [the options}.
So for now, the park plan is paused, not dead. Design work can’t start up again without a board vote at a public meeting, which means the people who packed the room this month will be able to see it coming.
They’ll probably be there. Reviewing the township’s long search for a police headquarters, one supervisor noted that these studies are always presented at public meetings. “Usually the room’s generally empty,” he said.
Not anymore. All it took was someone stopping long enough to read a plaque.


Leave your Comment